Best Pellet Stove On The Market 2016-2017: Review And Comparison

When it comes to your home’s utilities, heating is one of the most important and also the most costly. These days, most houses are heated with natural gas, but there is still something to be said for the old way of doing it, which was to burn wood. Even if your home doesn't have a fireplace, you can still warm up with wood with a pellet stove.

The best pellet stove is designed to burn compressed wood pellets, rather than traditional firewood. There are many benefits of pellet stoves, and today I’ll be showing you how and why to choose one for your home. I’ll also show you the best-rated pellet stoves out there so you can make an informed decision.

PRODUCTHEATSBURN TIMEBTUsEFFICIENCYDIMENSIONS
PRODUCTHEATSBURN TIMEBTUsEFFICIENCYDIMENSIONS
Pleasant Hearth Pellet Stove

up to 2200 sq ft24-70 hours500000.8624 x 26 x 25.8
Comfortbilt hp22

up to 2200 sq ft12-24 hours500000.8625 x 30 x 35
Comfortbilt - HP61

up to 2000 sq ft12-24 hours500000.8624 x 26 x 36
US Stove 5660

Up to 2,200 sq ft60 hours48,000NA26.2 x 24.2 x 30.
US Stove R5824

up to 1500 sq ftup to 20 hours30000NA21.5 x 33.5 x 20
US Wall Mount 4840

up to 1000 sq ftup to 28 hours24000NA36 x 14 x 27
Castle 12327 Serenity

up to 1500 sq ftup to 40 hours350000.7823.8 x 18.5 x 34

How to Choose the Best Pellet Stove

When going through pellet stove reviews, it can be easy to overlook what components are most important. When deciding on the right stove for your needs, what elements should you consider? Here are the top factors to look at when browsing pellet stove customer reviews.

Pellet Stove Hopper Extension: All pellet stoves come with a hopper, which is the name of the holding area for the pellets. Large units have a hopper that can hold 50 pounds or more while compact pellet stoves may only store up to 28 pounds of pellets at a time. The size of the hopper will determine a couple of things: first, how much heat can be generated, and second, how long it can operate before needing to be refilled. If you want your stove to be relatively maintenance-free, then a large hopper will help. Otherwise, most small hoppers require you to fill it once or twice a day, depending on how hot you like it.

Another thing to consider about the hopper is whether you load it from the top or bottom. The placement of the hopper can make it easier and more convenient to reload pellets, so keep that in mind

Power Requirements: Even though pellet stoves burn wood, many of them still need to plug into an outlet. Most stoves have electronic components, which are used to determine the heat level as well as when to put in more pellets. When choosing the best pellet stove, keep in mind what power requirements it has so that you won’t blow a fuse or trip a circuit breaker.

  • Pellet Stove Insert vs Freestanding: Many pellet stoves are free-standing units that have a vent leading to the outside. However, depending on the amount of heat you need and the amount of space you have, you may be able to get an insert model. Pellet stove insert is either small and compact and can mount to the wall, or are large and will install into the wall for a slimmer profile. When choosing the best pellet stove, keep in mind the size as well as where you want to place it.
  • Heat Out: Since pellet stoves come in a range of sizes, the heat generated also varies widely. When looking at pellet stoves, it should mention the amount of BTU’s it can generate, which will determine how much space it can warm up. For example, a 50,000 BTU stove can heat an area of 2200 square feet while a 25,000 BTU model can only heat up a thousand square feet. Keep in mind your space requirements and choose a model with sufficient output.

Top Rated 7 Best Pellet Stove Reviews 

​We researched the market and made a list of best pellet stove for you. You can choose one of them from the bellow.

1. Pleasant Hearth 2200 sq ft pellet stove with 80-Pound Hopper

Pellet Burning Stove insert

Pleasant Hearth - Pellet Burning Stove

​Feature Highlights:
  • 2200 square feet heating area
  • Item Weight is 171.4 pounds
  • 50000 BTU pellet burning stove
  • burn time: 16-46 hours
  • 80-pound hopper or 120 pound hopper
  • 85-percent efficiency rating
  • Auto Light Ignition
  • 5 Heat Settings
  • Outside air kit

First on our list is the pleasant hearth pellet stove reviews. If you want a classic style with modern conveniences, this pellet stove is right for you. As one of the best pellet stoves on the market, you can heat a relatively large area while still cutting down on your heating bills.

The Pleasant Hearth has an enormous 80-pound hopper, which can produce up to 50,000 BTU’s of heat. This amount of heat is capable of warming a space of up to 2200 square feet, making this unit ideal for large homes. The best part of this model is the long burning time, which, depending on your settings, can last between sixteen and 46 hours, enabling you to spend more time enjoying the heat than refilling the hopper.

Part of the reason that this pellet stove can provide so much heat is the level of efficiency it uses to burn the pellets. According to the EPA, the Pleasant Hearth has an 85% efficiency rating, meaning that more heat is produced and less energy wasted, which further cuts down on your fuel costs.

As far as modern conveniences, this model has five temperature settings so that you can adjust the heat level to your liking. It also features an automatic ignition, so you don’t have to worry about relighting the stove, just refilling it. Finally, this model features the ability to leave it on your desired heat setting, so you can keep your home just as warm as you like it.

The Pleasant Hearth is made in the USA and comes with a five-year limited warranty. This unit comes with an outside air kit and uses a convection blower.

Click bellow to See on Sylvane. com

2. Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22- 50,000 BTU

comfortbilt pellet stove reviews

comfortbilt hp22 review

​Feature Highlights:
  • 2000 sq ft heater
  • It is a 50000 btu heater
  • 86% Burn efficiency
  • 55 lbs. Hopper Capacity
  • Programmable Thermostat
  • Technical assistance available after purchase
  • 1 Year Parts Warranty
  • Auto Ignition
  • Powerful Blower, 110 Volt

When it comes to the best pellet stoves, two companies immediately come to mind. The first is Pleasant Hearth, and the second is Comfortbilt. We have two models from each company listed here, and the first from Comfortbilt is the HP22 Pellet Stove. This unit is a mix of the two previous models on this list, as it has both a high output and a compact design.

The HP22 uses a 55-pound hopper to generate up to 50,000 BTU’s of heat. Even though the hopper is smaller than other units, it still can pump out as much heat as a larger model. The amount of heat generated is enough to warm up to 2200 square feet, making this pellet stove ideal for large homes.

The HP22 uses a large convection blower to pump out the heat and has an efficiency rating of 86% by the EPA. The high rating is what allows this model to generate so much heat with such a small profile.

Modern conveniences come standard with all Comfortbilt products, and the HP22 has everything you need, including automatic ignition, electronic thermostat controls, programmable temperatures, and an ash pan for easy cleanup afterward. It even has a remote control so you can adjust everything no matter where you are. It is one of the best pellet stove on the market.

The HP22 is made in China and comes with a one-year limited warranty on parts and service.

Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP50 Review

Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22 Full Review

3. Comfortbilt Pellet Stove - HP61- 50,000 BTU

pellet stove reviews

Comfortbilt pellet stove reviews

​Feature Highlights:
  • 50,000 btu
  • 2000 sq ft heater 
  • 86% Burn efficiency with 110 Volt
  • 55 lbs. Hopper Capacity
  • 1 Year Parts Warranty
  • 3 inch pellet exhaust system
  • Auto Ignition, Programmable Thermostat and Ash Pan
  • Technical assistance after purchase
  • 36" High x 24" Wide x 26" Deep

The next model on our list from Comfortbilt is the HP61. When comparing this model to the HP22, there is not that much of a difference, save for the price. The HP61 is cheaper than its counter part by several hundred dollars, and it is slightly smaller and more compact. The other noticeable difference between the two is the fact that this model is square while the HP22 is octagonal. Otherwise, both models are still some of the best pellet stoves out there

The HP61 has a 55-pound hopper that is capable of generating up to 50,000 BTU’s of heat. The heat output makes this pellet stove ideal for large homes, as it can warm spaces up to 2000 square feet

Another great feature of the HP61 is the high-efficiency rating by the EPA. This model has a rating of 86%, which means that it wastes less energy and enables you to get the most out of your pellets. This model is also eligible for state tax credits since it produces less pollution.

Like the HP22, this model also uses a convection blower and is compatible with outside air kits

Like all Comfortbilt products, the HP61 has all the modern conveniences you could want. This pellet stove features automatic ignition, a programmable thermostat, electronic controls, and are movable ash pan for easy cleanup

This unit is made in China and comes with a one-year limited warranty on its parts and service.

Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP50 Full Review

Comfortbilt Pellet Stove HP22 Full Review

4. Forester pellet stove R5824 with Igniter Furnace (US Stove 4824 Review)

forester pellet stove 5824

us stove pellet stove reviews

​Feature Highlights:
  • Up to 20 hour burn time
  • Item Weight is 209 pounds
  • Large viewing window
  • Modern design
  • The 40 lb. hopper capacity
  • Product Dimensions is 21.5 x 33.5 x 20 inches
  • 30,000 btu. 3". Pipe 2" air
  • outside air compatible
  • with Igniter Furnace

Next on our list is the US Stove R5824. If you are looking for a more compact and cost-effective pellet stove, the R5824 is your answer. Read our wood pellet furnace reviews before taking any decision about it. This model is designed for smaller space and mobile homes, so if you’re looking for one of the best small pellet stoves, this unit is perfect for you.

The R5824 has a 40-pound hopper that generates up to 30,000 BTU’s of heat. This amount of heat is ideal for spaces up to 1000 feet, although in some cases it might be able to heat a space of 1200 feet. As far as burning time, this model can operate independently for up to 20 hours, so you only have to refill once a day, depending on your heating needs.

Like the Pleasant Hearth, this pellet stove is certified by the EPA and produces relatively clean air. It is not quite as efficient as the Pleasant Hearth model, but it still operates much better than comparable units.

The R5824 also has automatic ignition, electronic controls, and is compatible with open air kits. This model does not come with installation tools, but it is still relatively easy to install into any room or home.

5. Pleasant Hearth 1750-sq ft Pellet Stove with 40-Pound Hopper

pleasant hearth pellet stove review

pleasant hearth pellet stove

​Feature Highlights:
  • 1750 square feet heater
  • 35000 BTU
  • 40-pound hopper
  • Burn time: 12-24 hours
  • 85-percent efficiency rating
  • 5 Heat Settings
  • Auto Light Ignition
  • Includes an outside air kit and convection blower
  • 'Exclusive' Comfort Control System

Unlike Comfortbilt, the Pleasant Hearth company doesn’t designate its pellet stoves by model numbers or anything like that. Instead, when choosing the right stove from Pleasant Hearth, you have to go by size. Above I looked at the large stove, but now I’m going to show you the Medium size model. Pleasant Hearth offers three models: Medium, Large, and Cabinet size.

This medium-sized pellet stove uses a 40-pound hopper, which can generate up to 35,000 BTU’s of heat. The heat output of this model is ideal for spaces up to 1,750 square feet, which is perfect for smaller houses and mobile homes.

Much like the other models by Pleasant Hearth, the medium-sized stove has an efficiency rating of 85%, according to the EPA. The effectiveness of this unit allows it to operate independently for up to 24 hours, enabling you to refill the hopper less frequently.

This unit has the same modern features as the large model, which include automatic ignition, five heat settings, and a proprietary electronic comfort control system. This unit also allows you to keep it running at both the minimum and maximum settings so that you can maintain your desired heat level.

The medium-size pellet stove is made in the USA and comes with a five-year limited warranty. It also includes an outside air kit and uses a convection blower.

6. Castle Pellet Stove Serenity 12327 with Smart Controller

Castle 12327 Serenity Wood Pellet Stove

castle pellet stove reviews

​Feature Highlights:
  • More than 78percent thermal efficiency
  • EPA certified
  • Automatic ignition
  • Five feed rates and blower speeds
  • Dimensions 23.8 x 18.5 x 34 inches
  • Item Weight 186 pounds
  • 2800 square feet heating capacity
  • 40 pound pellet stove hopper extension

Nearing the end of our list, we now come to the Castle 12327 Serenity Pellet Stove. This model is much more compact than some of the others on this list, but it still provides exceptional heating and is one of the best pellet stoves for the money.

The Serenity Stove uses a forty pound hopper to generate up to 35,000 BTU’s of heat. The heat output is ideal for small homes, as it can warm a space of up to 1500 square feet

This model also features a high EPA efficiency rating of 86%. That means you can get the most heat out of your pellets, saving you money in the long run. The efficiency of operation also means that the Serenity can operate independently for up to 18 hours, so you only have to refill the hopper once a day

Much like the other pellet stoves on this list, the Serenity has many modern features that make it one of the best small units around. This model has automatic ignition, five feeding speeds so you can adjust the amount of pellets being burned, and a smart control system with remote so you can get your desired temperature no matter what.

The Serenity is made in China and comes with a one-year limited warranty.

7. United States Stove Company Wall Mount Pellet Stove 4840 reviews

1000 square feet heater

best heater for 1000 square feet

​Feature Highlights:
  • 1000 square feet heater
  • 3in. flue collar
  • Wall mounted pellet stove
  • Five heat settings
  • 120 CFM blower
  • 28 lb. hopper capacity
  • Up to a 28-hour run time
  • 24,000 BTU
  • Dimensions W x D x H (in.): 36 x 14 x 27

Finally, we come to the US Stove Company Wall-Mount Pellet Stove. Of all the units on this list, this pellet stove is by far the most compact, which is part of the reason you can mount it to the wall. However, just because it is the smallest, doesn’t mean that it isn’t just as effective as any other pellet stove.

The Wall Mounted Pellet Stove uses a 28-pound hopper to generate up to 24,000 BTU’s of heat. The output of this model is ideal for small spaces and mobile homes with a heating range of 1000 square feet.

As far as modern features, this pellet stove has five heat settings, a programmable thermostat, and automatic ignition. On the lowest setting, this unit can stay operational for up to 28 hours, enabling you to go longer without having to refill the hopper.

This pellet stove is made in the US and comes with a three-year limited warranty. 

Benefits and Downsides of Pellet Stoves

  • Pros
  • cons
  • Some units do not have as versatile control as a gas heater
  • Heavy and expensive
  • Have to be cleaned more frequently

Final Word

When comparing pellet stoves, the most important features are the amount of heat generated and the length of time it can operate before needing to be refilled. To that end, I prefer either model by Pleasant Hearth or the two Comfortbilt Stoves.

All of these units are best pellet stoves and have high-efficiency ratings and produce a lot of heat and need less refilling. However, that being said, if you have a small space or a mobile home, the Serenity or the Wall-Mounted US Stove model are my best picks for compact size and hopper capacity.